Keeping the Faith

1 In this case don't keep the faith!!!
This movie is one of the worst movies I have seen in a long, long, time... I feel horrible that I wasted money renting this movie. I also thought maybe this religious comedy would have as much charm as Saved had- but, I was wrong...Also being a Ben Stiller fan I figured that I should give this flick a shot.

The story centers around three child-hood friends who grew up together in New York Jake, Brian, and their tom-boyish friend Anna. When Anna moves away Jake and Brian are left to themselves... Jake eventually becoming a rabbi and Brian becoming a Catholic priest- both of them trying to reach their congergations with new-age techniques using bongo drums, high powered songs, and sermons with meaning-- even going to the extent of opening a inter-faith karaoke naming themselves the "God Squad"... Well Anna returns to New York all grown up and beautiful work addict. With a position opening up for head rabbi at Jake's temple he is sent on a series of horrible dates so he can marry a nice Jewish girl before long he realizes how much he cares for Anna-- only problem she's not Jewish. And to top that off Jake realizes he cares for her as well...

All in all it sounds about as good as the plot is which is horrible... this movie has nothing to do with faith, meaning, or purpose like "Saved!" delievered and it's not one of Ben Stiller's more charming performances. Jenna Elfman is also no actress.

If you want a smart and endearing movie about all the things you are searching for purpose, meaning, love, then buy "Saved!" and forget "Keeping the Faith."

2 A refreshing movie about religion
Top to bottom this movie is very good. On its simplest level it is an Arthurian romance (all three characters care deeply about one another and form an odd and dysfunctional love triangle). On this level it is a comedy and a decent movie.

At a deeper level it talks about the priests vow of celebacy, a rabbi and a gentile relationship, and how profoundly faith enters the picture for two "young" men (and, indirectly, a young woman) looking for a relationship.

My favorite scenes in the whole movie were where the older "spiritual guides" come across as strong mentors rather than stick-in-the-mud characters.

Rabbi Lewis: I know, I know, you like to shake things up and that's good, but sometimes people need to feel led instead of pushed.

Older priest: That is my recruitment pitch. It makes you feel like a marine. The truth is that no matter what you do in life it is a choice, a choice you make every day. I've been a priest for over 40 years and have fallen in love at least once every decade.

These are all refreshing images in a culture increasingly hostile to these two ancient faiths. The characters actually grow and change, find out more about themselves and one another. About the meaning of friendship and honesty.

Rabbi Jake: Whoa, whoa, whoa. Do you hear what you are saying? You are complaining that I wasn't sensitive to the fact that my friend, A CATHOLIC PRIEST, might have a CRUSH on my SECRET GIRLFRIEND?!

3 Tame Ben Stiller Romantic Comedy
IF you like Ben Stiller but tend to think he goes over the top in most of his films, this may be a film for you. Even with such a cliched premise (so a priest and a rabbi are friends...), the characters came across as real people, so that I really got into the story. It's funny but sweet; it's a nice movie to watch while cuddled up with a loved one.

4 got to have faith
This is an excellent movie. It is one of the best romantic- comedy films. The chemistry between the three leads makes this a powerful story. Well written- a nice balance of drama and humor.

5 A priest, a rabbi and a girl named Anna
"Keeping the Faith" is Edward Norton's debut as a director and he is does a good job. The story starts out funny. Norton (a priest) sits in a bar telling a story to an Irish/Sikh/muslim/jewish bartender about how he and his best rabii-friend (Stiller) are fighting over a girl. Well, you have to see for yourself, it's funny. Jenna Elfman is so incredibly beautiful and funny in this movie, who wouldn't fall for her!?

The end of the film is a little too serious to my taste, even though we could have known that something like this would happen. It gives a little dark edge to an otherwise fun movie.

6 Such potential...
This movie had so much potential. Especially with Edward Norton as the director, a great cast and an interesting and pertinant issue at hand. However, the movie turns into your normal, run of the mill romantic comedy once Jenna Elfman comes on the scene. Watch "You've Got Mail" or "Sleepless in Seattle" for much the same effect.

There's a lot of really interesting issues that Norton neglects to explore in this film. Brian Finn, the priest, questions his calling to the priesthood and then writes it off. Elfman's character is totally ignorant of the challenges that come with leading a religious community. Rabbi Schram's (Stiller) relationship with Elfman is weak at best--all they ever do is have sex. Where's the spiritual side that he's craving? These are just some of the problems with the film. There are plenty more.

If you're looking for a cheezy romantic commedy, this is the movie for you. If you're looking for someone taking issues of religious difference into the mainstream, read a book.

7 Fun Romantic Comedy
Okay, so you get an Irish Catholic Priest and a Jewish Rabbi who had a tom-boy friend when they were kids and you have a great idea for a movie.

Who thinks of these things anyway??

Stiller and Norton, although not looking like they would be friends, do a great job of acting like it. Their characters come together well, especially after Anna (Jenna Elfman) returns to NY for a career move after being away since she was young girl.

The flash back and then forward sequence is excellent. You almost forget where the movie started because there are so many cute twists to the movie.

There is also a lesson in the movie, one of love and compromise and you get a sense of the challenges people face when they make life choices as far as career, marriage and family issues.

This is a fun movie, good for the DVD library. The language is a little harsh in places, yet, it is an okay film.

8 2 men fancy 1 woman. 17th april 2004.
Edward norton and ben stiller play 2 jenna elfman lovers. Brian [norton] and jake[stiller], have known a girl now a woman for as long as they can remember. They have both been good friends to her since childhood, and she falls in love with brian. He as been going out with her for a while now, and she soon falls in love with jake. She starts going bed with jake still brian dosen't know, and he carries on as normal. In the end, it all comes out. Jake dumps her because they are different religions and the best thing for him is to leave her even though he still fancies her. Brian makes friends with jake and jake and anna are back together he caught her in time when she was about to leave town for good. They are all bestest mates even though she is jakes girlfriend still. SEEN IT OVER AND OVER AGAIN AND NEVER BORED OF IT STILL.

9 Have Some Faith, This is a Good Romantic Comedy
Edward Norton`s directing debut focuses the story of three long-time friends, a priest (Norton himself), a rabi (Ben Stiller) and a business woman (Jenna Elfman). This friendship will turn into a troubled romantic love triangle, questioning the power of faith, trust, friendship and love. It`s funny enough, even if not hilarious, and the characters are deeper than those of an average comedy, especially Edward Norton`s priest, quite credible and realistic. As a whole, the movie is a fine, hip and witty NY love story, avoiding the usual sapiness as it doesn`t get too romantic and lame. Of course, the ending is predictable and happy as ever, but it doesn`t seem too forced and actually makes sense. A good movie for the twentysomethings.

10 a wonderful directing debut from Edward Norton
Edward Norton(25th Hour, Fight Club, The Score), Ben Stiller(Duplex, Along Came Polly, Zoolander) and Jenna Elfman(Cant Hardly Wait and tv's Dharma and Greg) star as 3 friends. Norton becomes a preist, Stiller a rabbi and Elfman becomes a succesful buisness woman. both men are in love with Elfman and things heat up. the highlight of this movie would be when Stiller tries to get to Elfman and the security guard hassels him..(the part where Stiller sees Elfman, runs in and the security puts out his arm and smacks him down..hilarious)..also where Stiller has all those Jewish trading cards(a hoot as well)..Norton has his moments (when Stiller is watching the briss and Norton drops the smoke thing on his robe and it lights on fire..he runs and parks his behind in holy water...great).. lacks some things but all in all its an interesting view

11 A funny, perky comedy
I find this movie to be very funny and lighthearted. Simply put its entertaining and thats what a comedy should be.

12 Great love story.
Edward Norton, Ben Stiller and Jenna Elfman all turn in fantastic performances in this bubblegum love triangle story. This movie is just really fun and cute. Both Ben and Edward are hilarious in this. Pick up your copy today.

13 Ignorance
As a romantic comedy it's standard fare. Ben Stiller does his usual array of funny facial expressions, and the female interest is very watchable. My main problem was Stiller's character's supreme ignorance of the arab-israeli dispute. It seemed as though he was trying to trivialise it. Coming from a supposed Rabbi - this was insensitive in the extreme. If this subject had to be brought into a harmless rom-com, then surely it could have been done with maybe a little more tact? Not all of us see suicide bombings and the humiliation of a people as light hearted rom com material.

14 very entertaining
This is a tale of three childhood friends. It's funny but not over the top. One of the friends moves away and the two boys are left to grow up. But years later, the girl comes back. Sparks fly when they both begin to fall in love with her all over again. It's great fun.

15 Conflicts when worlds collide
This is an interesting movie of three nice and decent people whose settled inter-relationship in one stage of life is suddenly and unexpectedly threatened in another stage. Many of us are lucky enough to make lasting friendships in school; sadly for one reason or another (relocation, different colleges, varying careers), many of these friendships fade away.

This is a story of two boys and a girl whose friendship as children was as good as it could get. Now years later, the boys are into religion: one (Norton) an ordained Catholic priest working with youth, the other (Stiller) a Jewish rabbi •À?auditioning•À? for a congregation. Meanwhile, in a nice little twist, the girl (Elfman) has become a high powered businesswoman. The movie explores what happens when they meet again. The friendship is every bit as good as it used to be •À? the days seem hardly to have passed. But as adults, they have new priorities, new ambitions that complicate the picture. Happy as Norton is with his vocation, Elfman awakens questions in him (of relationships, of marriage, of sex) that he thought were settled, but in fact has no answers for. Stiller has other problems with his evident attraction to Elfman and hers•À? for him. A rabbi unlike a priest is free (in fact almost expected!) to marry; yet marriage to a girl who is not Jewish (she is catholic) would jeopardize his ambition to be rabbi of an influential congregation where he can make a difference. Both Norton and Stiller are simultaneously battling conservative elders to draw more youth to their respective services. Elfman herself seems to be weighing career and family options. These are no perfect cut-outs; they are basically decent people with human flaws. Faced with choices that impact their fundamental beliefs, they struggle, make mistakes, hurt themselves and each other. The ending may be predictable, but they way Norton (who also directs) gets to the end is top quality. The film is filled with vignettes of humor. It does not preach but tries to understand the terrible conflicts that arise when worlds collide. I enjoyed the movie and before I end, let me recommend the bonus scene on the DVD of Anna and the vibrating cell phone (I will not say more lest I spoil it for you) which is hilarious.

16 You Gotta Have Faith
If you look carefully enough at the trailer of every movie, you can pretty much tell whether or not it's a rental. I did in fact take my girlfriend at the time to see this movie, and it succeeded as both a date movie, and a trite little tale about religion in the 90's.

In the latter case, the film probably works a lot better--I agree with most of the reviewers about the pairing of the Ben Stiller (Jake) and Jenna Elfman (Dhar... I mean, Anna); that there's not much onscreen chemistry between them. Elfman is the real problem--her jump from TV to the big screen just isn't convincing.

That being said, there are a number of great one-liners, mostly relating to modern-day religion, and the strength of the film's first half is JUST enough to forgive the weakness of the second half. Anybody in this day and age who's had problems with his/her faith would enjoy this film for what it is. A simple, light-hearted comedy with its heart in the right place.

Besides, my mum loved it.

17 hot and cool
"Who is the coolest woman you have ever known?"
"That's easy: Anna Riley, in eighth grade."

Keeping the Faith is a really sweet and funny film about a rabbi, a priest, and a hot and successfull business woman who get together again for the first time since 8th grade, when they were best friends all three of them. As you can imagine, the faith issues, the friendship, and the fact that they all now have adult desires makes for a messy story, but a lot of fun.

The reason I review it on this site is simple: Jenna Elfman. In short, she is not only cool, she is also HOT. The clincher is the extra scene, cut from the film but made it onto the DVD's bonuses, of Jenna (Anna) and her vibrating cell phone. I don't recall having seen a scene before that was both funny and so sexy I could hardly sleep after. Get the DVD if you can.

Favorite quote: "I know what an intimate relationship you have with your cell phone, and I thought I'd get in on the action."

18 Sweet romantic comedy, made better by its cast
What can you say about Edward Norton? Acquiring quite the cult following many people are seeking out all of his films just to watch his performance, and I am one of them. Here he acts in, directs and co-produces a movie of a kind that he's never been in before: a romantic comedy. And it fares pretty well compared to similar films. The story concerns two best friends, a rabbi and a priest, who are both in love with the same girl from their childhood. Norton's the priest, Stiller the rabbi and Elfman the girl.

Of course this is the kind of predicatable stuff romantic comedies are made out of, but there is a little something else here that does make you take more notice. Of course there are the performances. Norton at first seems to be taking on a role where he takes himself less seriously, yet as the movie progresses the small intricacies of his performance become apparent, in particular his internal struggle between faith and love. Stiller is a real shock in that he not only acts out the slapstick humour with his usual aplomb but also the dramatic elements with an ease that surely cries out for some more serious roles. Elfman is also a complete joy, managing to be self-asserted, fun and vulnerable all at the same time. Having never seen Dharma and Greg I was completely unaware of what a charismatic actress she was, but judging by this film she hopefully has great things ahead of her.

Another point of the movie that makes it at least stand out from the crowd somewhat is its discussion of priorities, faith, religion, work and love. Whilst obviously more pertinent to the 30-somethings that Keeping The Faith is understandably aimed at (after all, Norton is one himself), this by no way means that it is alienating to any other audience. Speeches about whether finding love or getting a good job should be your main priority may seem slightly ill-judged when coming out of the characters' mouths, they at least seem a realistic protrayal of what they are thinking, even if it doesn't sound like something they'd actually say.

Before the movie descends into clichŽ with a last run to get the girl and a smiling photo snap, there is also a lot of light humour that is carried very deftly by Norton and Stiller. In particular, the introduction of their religions is particularly inspired, creating harmless fun from a very touchy area. Whilst this may never be a classic in its own right, this is gentle watching that is a touch above other romantic comedies simply because its characters are all too endearing and fun to make you reach for your sick buckets. Whilst it may not be entirely original, that doesn't mean that there's no originality in it, and it marks an impressive directorial debut from Norton.

19 Delving Deeper
I have a bone to pick with just about every movie critic in the known universe. Each and every one of them acts shocked and dismayed when a romantic comedy turns out to be *gasp!* predictible, and then they feel the need to make snide comments about the acting, the plot, the storyline...

What gets lost in all this is the fact that many highly intelligent people enjoy watching these movies because they are FUN. Even if I know (or think I know) how a movie will turn out in the end, I can still have FUN while I'm getting there. You know what fun is, right? It's that thing where you're happy and not uptight--you remove the stick from your butt for awhile and just ENJOY yourself. What a concept. And I was in the mood to enjoy myself one night, didn't want to think too deeply, so I decided to rent "Keeping The Faith."

Wow. I have to state here that I'm pretty wary of movies that portray "religious" people of any kind, because I'm sick and tired of stereotypes. Let me assure my fellow "religious" people: this movie doesn't wuss out. The catholic Priest isn't an uptight jerk, and he isn't a total saint. He's *shock" Edward Norton: a NICE GUY who feels called to his work and wants to make a difference. The Rabbi isn't some wise old guy who's used as a plot device to deliver either crucial advice or comic relief. Instead, he's Ben Stiller--a pretty nice younger guy who's torn between pleasing others and doing what's right for himself. The priest and the rabbi have been friends since childhood. When another childhood friend comes back into their lives after years of separation, they both fall in love with her. Oops.

The Priest doubts his calling when he struggles with his love for a woman who happens to be in love with his best friend, and the Rabbi alternates between struggling to make faith seem real to the people in his congregation and lashing out/ hurting his friends/ being a total jerk. Surprise! These are real people. They're not always nice. Their faith isn't a crutch, it isn't a band aid, it isn't an insult to the audience. It's a real and living thing that they struggle to understand as they try to pass it on to others.

The Rabbi falls in love with a woman who doesn't share his faith. Oh no! What will people think? What should he do? Jenna Elfman's speech to him about how she admires his faith and she's trying to understand it even though it's not easy for her is one of the most touching moments in a movie chock full of touching moments. Maybe that's why the critics didn't like this movie. Critics seem to hate touching moments. Touching moments happen all the time in real life, that's why they're predictable.

I expected to have fun with this movie, and I did--rolling with laughter more than once. But I was also enlightened and rewarded with a film that allowed me to think a little deeper about everything I hold dear.

While the priest and the rabbi never walk into a bar together, the movie still manages to be funny. And the love story is everything love stories should be: sappy, sweet, and ultimately satisfying. As an added bonus, you can ponder some deeper questions of faith and savor the unexpected delight of seeing true friendship realistically portrayed. Relax, take a deep breath, remove the stick from your butt, and enjoy.

20 Wonderful Movie
A really sweet and wonderful film. I enjoyed it all the way through.

21 Have you heard the one about .....
Have you heard the one about the priest, the rabbi, and the business executive? No, well watch this movie then.
This film was just not what I expected. Perhaps I excpect better out of two guys who have made much better pictures. Stiller has a had a hit or two, although I think he's much better as a member of the supporting cast. And just about everything Edward Norton does is good. But this movie just lacked chemistry and any sense of real movement.

22 Surprisingly pleasant sleeper
My wife and I had never heard of this one, until it appeared on Pay Per View television. Now I've seen it three times, including this past weekend with my parents.

There's a slight slowdown for perhaps the third fifth of the movie, but the rest is really quite charming. The writing is witty, the acting is comfortable, and the direction and editing are both quite smart.

23 You can keep it.
Edward Norton is to be commended, perhaps, for not attempting to make *Apocalypse Now* on his first try out. Still, one can't help but be puzzled that he (Mr. American-History-X) would latch onto such a non-threatening, non-interesting, mainstream romantic comedy as *Keeping the Faith* for his directorial debut. The two main characters are based on real-life men: a media-savvy rabbi-and-priest team -- I forget their names -- who call themselves the "God Squad". Unlike the real God Squad, Ben Stiller and Edward Norton (rabbi and priest, respectively) are young, hip, wear leather jackets, display jovial impertinence to their elders, blah blah. Suddenly, a female childhood chum (Jenna Elfman) turns up and wreaks havoc on these smug twits. Elfman, by the way, is miscast here: she's supposed to be some sort of high-powered corporate exec, the type that keeps her cell phone tucked into her stocking-garter while dining at fancy restaurants. (Jenna ELFMAN?) This actress is a very funny lady, radiating genuine charm and wholesome sexiness, and saves *Keeping the Faith* from being irremediable. Before she shows up, we have to put up with hoary slapstick -- priest-and-rabbi shtick -- such as Stiller passing out at a briss and Norton setting his own vestment afire with a wildly swinging censer. Once she arrives, Norton calms down and attempts to make a comedy of character. Albeit ineptly, but he tries. In any case, one comes away from the movie feeling that Elfman deserves a better love-triangle than one involving such skinny twerps as Ben Stiller and Edward Norton.

24 A Charming Film
I think this is a charming movie. The characters are likeable, it's very funny, and has a heartwarming message without being cheesy or smarmy. A great "date" movie and appropriate fun for older children (some romantic (not sex) scenes not okay for younger viewers).

25 Nice and fun movie!
This movie was more fun then I had expect it to be, I would give it 3 1/2 stars if I can but not 4 stars this movie is fun but very clichŽ. Good performance from the actors but sometime Jenna Elfman gets on my nerves but she's funny most of the time and a good actress. It's a good and funny movie to watch but I felt it could had been more to the story, I don't know exactly what but something is missing and I feel that was odd that the girl get with (Ben) and (Norton) is all okay with it at the end, I thought he love her, well anyways go rent it if you want to past a relaxing evening at home with a funny movie to get out the stress of the day or of the week.

26 So funny, but I had a hard time with Ed Norton as a priest..
I LOVED this movie!!! Ben Stiller, Jenna Elfman, and Ed Norton make an excellent comical team!!! My favorite part is when Father Brian goes to pick up Rabbi Schram while Anna is over at his apartment. Catholics who befriend Jews and Jews who befriend Catholics, are sure to appreiate this movie. The only aspect of the movie that bothered me was that Ed Norton played a priest because I think he is so HOT and I had a hard time gawking at him while he was in cleric's clothing.

27 Good Romantic Comedy
Keeping The Faith (2000) is a light, entertaining and contemporary romantic comedy. The setup sounds very corny but it works. Jacob, played by Ben Stiller is Jewish. Brian, played by Edward Nortan, is Irish Catholic, and Anna, played by Jenna Elfman, is an Irish Catholic girl. All three were best friends growing up in Brooklyn. In the eighth grade, Anna's family moves to California. Remaining best friends, Jacob grows up to become a rabbi, Brian a priest. When they are in their thirties, Ruth contacts Brian to tell him she is coming to New York for a few weeks. Jacob and Brian have not seen or spoken to Anna in twenty years. She is now a high-powered businesswoman. Jacob and Brian meet her at the airport together.

The actress Jennie Elfman's looks are quite captivating. She is very tall, taller than both guys, very thin and very blonde. Both men's passions ignite and burn wild. The rest of the movie is a love triangle made interesting because of all the things that priests and rabbis are not supposed to do.

I liked the scenes involving the synagogue congregation. It's not something that one sees in many movies. I felt that the image of the priest as sexually emasculated was very sad. A fair attempt is made at balancing it, but it fails. Other actors you may recognize in the film are Ann Bancroft who plays Jacob's mother and Ron Rifkin who plays a senior rabbi. Milos Forman who plays Brian's pastor has a good scene near the end, counseling Brian.

28 Huh?
Maybe it's just me, but, aren't rabbis and priests "men of the cloth?" Never mind that it is frowned upon when rabbis date non-Jewish women, but sleep with them??? And is a priest so faithless that all his religious training and the sacred vows he took are tossed aside when some pretty girl who floats into town flirts with him? Well, folks, that's what happens. Now, the girl in question is one who neither the rabbi nor the priest have seen or talked to in 15 years, since their parting as children. And when she comes into town on business they suddenly both fall head over heels for her ... solely on her looks. And Jenna Elfman is attractive, but it's a little unbelievable that a rabbi and a priest would so shamelessly gawk at her like two boys ogling a centerfold. Aren't religious leaders supposed to embody self-restraint?

I couldn't think of a single reason why either one of these supposedly very dedicated religious men would be so dreamily attracted to this high-powered businesswoman, who they really don't know anymore, since they haven't seen her in a decade and a half. Jenna Elfman doesn't give them a reason, either. She's work-obsessed, bossy, and she has nothing in common with either of them except that they were friends in junior high school. Are they supposed to see through that to the real her? Ben Stiller (the rabbi) and Edward Norton (the priest) claim that she's special. But they really haven't gotten a chance to know her. They're actually more in lust, which seems somewhat far-fetched, given their religious background. Eventually, Stiller and Elfman begin sleeping together, and claim to have fallen in love. This is hard to buy as most of their scenes together are of them having sex. In the meantime, Norton starts dreaming of Elfman, and misinteprets her flirtations as gestures of true love, at which point he's ready to call the whole priest thing quits. And this is after he's told Elfman how he's at peace with his vow of chastity.

Nobody would believe either male character has had an ounce of religious training. They drink, swear, take the Lord's name in vain, and conduct religious services like stand-up comedians. The rationale for this last behavior is that it brings people to church. Obviously it's a comedy, but the actions and faithlessness of Stiller and Norton render them completely unconvincing as spiritual leaders. The attempts to paint the religious men as still just human beings fails because they never seemed convinced themselves of their own faith to begin with. I'm not sure what message this film is trying to send. Modern religious leaders are weak, faithless people, generally prone to sinful acts? True love grows out of flirting, erotic dreams, and pre-marital sex? You should only go to church if it's entertaining? There are lines throughout the film that try to justify the "unbelievability" of the events which occur. This in itself seems to indicate that those who made the film knew it was too far-fetched, and had to in some way rationalize it. Of course, this only makes things worse.

Eli Wallach, Anne Bancroft, and Milos Forman all add nice touches of acting clout in supporting roles. And there are a couple of funny scenes here and there. But they can't save this film. Comedy or not, two-dimensional characters and a ridiculous storyline do not a good film make.

29 Huh?
Maybe it's just me, but, aren't rabbis and priests "men of the cloth?" Never mind that it is frowned upon when rabbis date non-Jewish women, but sleep with them??? And is a priest so faithless that all his religious training and the sacred vows he took are tossed aside when some pretty girl who floats into town flirts with him? Well, folks, that's what happens. Now, the girl in question is one who neither the rabbi nor the priest have seen or talked to in 15 years, since their parting as children. And when she comes into town on business they suddenly both fall head over heels for her ... solely on her looks. And Jenna Elfman is attractive, but it's a little unbelievable that a rabbi and a priest would so shamelessly gawk at her like two boys ogling a centerfold. Aren't religious leaders supposed to embody self-restraint?

Nobody would believe either male character has had an ounce of religious training. They drink, swear, take the Lord's name in vain, and conduct religious services like stand-up comedians. The rationale for this last behavior is that it brings people to church. Obviously it's a comedy, but the actions and faithlessness of Stiller and Norton render them completely unconvincing as spiritual leaders. The attempts to paint the religious men as still just human beings fails because they never seemed convinced themselves of their own faith to begin with. I'm not sure what message this film is trying to send. Modern religious leaders are weak, faithless people, generally prone to sinful acts? True love grows out of flirting, erotic dreams, and pre-marital sex? You should only go to church if it's entertaining? There are lines throughout the film that try to justify the "unbelievability" of the events that occur. This in itself seems to indicate that those who made the film knew it was too far-fetched, and had to in some way rationalize it. Of course, this only makes things worse.

Eli Wallach, Anne Bancroft, and Milos Forman all add nice touches of acting clout in supporting roles. And there are a couple of funny scenes here and there. But they can't save this film. Two-dimensional characters and an incredulous storyline do not a good film make.

30 Huh?
Maybe it's just me, but, aren't rabbis and priests "men of the cloth?" Never mind that it is frowned upon when rabbis date non-Jewish women, but sleep with them??? And is a priest so faithless that all his religious training and the sacred vows he took are tossed aside when some pretty girl who floats into town flirts with him? Well, folks, that's what happens. Now, the girl in question is one who neither the rabbi nor the priest have seen or talked to in 15 years, since their parting as children. And when she comes into town on business they suddenly both fall head over heels for her ... solely on her looks. And Jenna Elfman is attractive, but it's a little unbelievable that a rabbi and a priest would so shamelessly gawk at her like two boys ogling a centerfold. Aren't religious leaders supposed to embody self-restraint?

Nobody would believe either male character has had an ounce of religious training. They drink, swear, take the Lord's name in vain, and conduct religious services like stand-up comedians. The rationale for this last behavior is that it brings people to church. Obviously it's a comedy, but the actions and faithlessness of Stiller and Norton render them completely unconvincing as spiritual leaders. The attempts to paint the religious men as still just human beings fails because they never seemed convinced themselves of their own faith to begin with. I'm not sure what message this film is trying to send. Modern religious leaders are weak, faithless and generally prone to sinful acts? True love grows out of flirting, erotic dreams, and pre-marital sex? You should only go to church if it's entertaining? There are lines throughout the film that try to justify the "unbelievability" of the events that occur. This in itself seems to indicate that those who made the film knew it was too far-fetched, and had to in some way rationalize things. Of course, this only makes things worse.

Eli Wallach, Anne Bancroft, and Milos Forman all add nice touches of acting clout in supporting roles. And there are a couple of funny scenes here and there. But they can't save this film. Two-dimensional characters and an incredulous storyline do not a good film make.

31 much better than I anticipated
I had no desire to see this movie, but I had run out of Stiller movies, and so I had no choice. It ended being such a funny, enjoyable, and cute film that I can say that any move Ben Stiller is in is gonna be great, and I will never doubt Edward Norton again, either. His directing is superb--he keeps it really spontaneous and honest and real rather than glossy and scripted. Even though the actual premise is admittedly pretty farfetched, there is a lot of truth to the emotions and human reactions, making it a very moving movie. Jenna Elfman is a real treat, she is very very gifted--who knew???? So definitely rent this movie.

32 a great date movie
They say Faith can move mountains. They say Faith can get you through the turmoil of life. What happens though when your Faith in God runs headlong into your Love of a woman? Can the two exist if the woman is of a different Faith? Can it exist if you are the leader of your denomination? Ed Norton's directorial debut examines this in what could be a serious movie but is a very funny romantic movie.
We start with Father Brian Finn, Ed Norton, stumbling drunk and landing in an all night bar. He ends up telling the story to a world-weary bartender who claims to have heard it all. The bartender knew he had heard it all when it started with, "There's this Priest and a Rabbi..." Actually the story doesn't start there though.
Approximately 16 years early Brian Finn and Jacob Schram, two best friends, met their soul mate Anna Riley. She was the kind of girl all boys wanted to be around, cute but not too girlish. These three are never seen without each other. Disaster strikes 2 years later when Anna's father is moved across the country to New York. The three occasionally keep in touch through letters but think that their partnership is over.
We jump to the future where the two boys have taken interesting jobs. It seems Brian and Jake, Ben Stiller, have always had a calling and that calling was to preach the word. Brian has become a Priest and Jake is now a Rabbi. Both are the hottest things to hit their respective Church's and are shaking things up with contemporary ideas. They are even jokingly known in the streets as "The God Squad." They reach some opposition from the old-line members of their respective congregations however the increased numbers at each service is hard to argue with.
One fine day Brian informs Jake that their old friend, Anna is going to be coming to New York for work and wants to get together with them. Both are stunned to find their gangly tomboyish friend has grown up to be a stunning workaholic played by Jenna Elfman.
Here's where the story really gets interesting. The three friends begin palling around again and getting to know everything about them. Anna is basically the proto-typical 2000 woman. She is so busy working that she rarely has time to go out with men in fact as she puts it, she has a relationship with her phone. Anna is more interested in getting to know about the two guys. She finds it fascinating that the two men are so dedicated to their churches and attends services at both. She also is interested in knowing how they are going to get their Catholic/Jewish Community Center opened. However what interests her the most is the men's relationship issues. She quizzes Brian about his faith and of course about his vow...the big vow...and wants to know what is going on with Jake and his women. I say women because all the women at the Synagogue are desperate to get their daughters married off to the young Rabbi. This leads to a couple of wonderful dates for Jake.
Problems occur with all this time spent together though. Brian begins to question his vows of Celibacy more and more as he is around Anna. Even more of a problem though occurs between Anna and Jake as they fall in love. This wouldn't be too much of a problem if Jake was just your normal attendee of the Synagogue however being a Rabbi up for his own church? Well let's just say it isn't looked upon too well to be going out with a blonde Irish girl if you want to lead a Synagogue.
Since this is a Romantic/Comedy we know how it is going to end. The pleasure of the movie is watching how they get there. All three actors deliver superb performances. We knew Ed Norton was a great actor but Ben Stiller and Jenna Elfman more than stand with him in terms of comedic timing and drama. I was doubly impressed that Jenna, unlike some other television actresses, was able to successfully shed her television persona for a new gig.
The dialogue was rapid fire and funny. The timing of the movie was also well paced. We had seen early evidence of Ed Norton's abilities when he helped out trimming down American History X and he continues to do a great job with the reins fully in his hands. This was definitely worth full price at the theater and is a great Date Movie.

33 DVD has great extras for this charming movie
This is one of those films that you just fall into. Like one of my other favorites, The Cutting Edge, the movie was modest at the box office but came out like gangbusters when it came out on video. That is how I discovered the film.

I remember seeing the ads and cringing slightly, knowing there was going to be a romantic theme and Edward Norton played a Catholic priest. Norton and Ben Stiller as his best friend, a Jewish Rabbi, have great chemistry. Add Jenna Elfman as their favorite "girl" friend from childhood and you've got yourself a romantic triangle.

Of course, I knew how the movie was going to end up at the end, but I still enjoyed it. The DVD has deleted scenes and a blooper reel that is hilarious.

34 Affable and innocent. Runs a bit too long.
Edward Norton burst on the scene by playing a psychopathic killer in 1996's Primal Fear. His reputation was secured afterwards by his performances as a reformed neo-Nazi in American History X and as the nameless narrator in Fight Club. it is perhaps not so surprising that he chose to balance this tendency towards seriousness by choosing a romantic comedy for his first directorial job. The result is Keeping the Faith, an affable and charming movie whose main fault is its rather long running time. This is a weakness common among actors turned director. It was probably inevitable that Norton should also do this, as his best friend, Stuart Blumberg, wrote the script. More on that later.

Brian Finn and Jake Scram [Norton and Ben Stiller] have been friends since childhood. Brian is an Irish Catholic lad, while Jake is a Jew. In the marvelous melting pot that is New York City, this is not at all an uncommon union. What turns out to be unusual is that Brain becomes a priest and Jake a rabbi. When they were kids, there was a third best pal, a girl named Anna Riley [Jenna Elfman]. She moved away in the eighth grade and eventually became but a memory. In the first part of the movie, Anna returns to New York and hooks up with her old buddies. She has become a beautiful and successful young woman. Jake and Brian are both smitten, and therein lies the crux of the comedy. Brian, of course, has his vow of chastity, which until Anna's arrival seems to have not been a problem for him. As for Jake, his congregation assumes that this most eligible bachelor will choose a nice Jewish girl. There is a lot of pressure on Jake, who is barraged by mothers pushing their daughters on him. In one of the movie's funniest scenes, Jake's date with Ali Decker [Lisa Edelstein] turns into one that he will never forget. How will Brian and Jake resolve the Anna dilemma, which threatens both their friendship and their careers? Isn't this a no win situation for all three?

One of the movie's big advantages is that Edward Norton and Stuart Blumberg really are an Irish kid and a Jewish one being best friends. They are New Yorkers and have lived together for several years. As a result, they were able to find New York locations rarely seen on film. This give the picture a fresh look and also makes the city look much more livable than it often does. The acting is first rate, as you would expect. Norton does have a flair for comedy, although he needs to work a bit on the physical aspects of it. Ben Stiller is one of the funniest men alive, and Jenna Elfman departs for once from her famous television persona. The running time of over two hours is excessive for this type of entertainment and slows the film down, but it does not ruin it by any means. It is simply something Norton should be aware of on his next project.

Perhaps the best thing about Keeping the Faith is its innocence. Lately there have been a number of often good but quite cynical comedies. It is godd to see one where you can laugh at your fellow man and still feel great about the human race.

35 Faith in this Movie
Nortan (Fight Club; American History X), Elfman (Sitcom "Dharma and Greg"), and Stiller (Meet the Parents) light it up in this warm-hearted comedy about 3 friends from grade school who haven't seen each other in year, now thrown back together when Elfman comes running back into their lives. Nortan and Stiller, now clergymen, (Nortan a Catholic Priest, Stiller a Jewish Rabbi) both find the old friendship they once knew in their beloved tom-boyish beauty of a friend Elfman. But throughout it all, there is denial, lying, antitrust, and a passionate love triangle forms. Now who will end up following their faith and who will end up following their hearts? Nortan, Elfman, and Stiller deliver a spectacular and heart gripping performance in this romantic comedy that shouldn't be missed by men nor women alike.

36 Find someone to cuddle with
Find someone to cuddle with and curl up to watch this adorable movie. Norton's direction is amazing and the scenes with Stiller and Elfman make me wish they were really a couple. Norton's scenes in the bar are especially funny, but his wonderful direction is the real star.

37 Offensive To Just ABout Everybody
Once again hollywood has created a film that denigrates Jews and African Americans. The film is full of stereotypes; happy guythat love to sing and rejoice, a big bad nigger that loves to fight. Of course, we don't really know his name because he constantly referred to as "T-Bone." Let's see what else, materialistic jews that lack spirituality and the good white christian who is real and feeling. I'm sorry but I do not find Stepinfetchit characterizations of black people funny, no matter how minor or superfluous the roles are in the films.

38 The Religious Odd Couple
KEEPING THE FAITH starts out extremely promising. Ben Stiller and Edward Norton portray a rabbi and a priest... and also best of friends. We follow them as they are introduced to their respective congregations. Their youth and fresh perspective reaches more and more people, a much needed boost in attendance and is frankly a pleasure to watch. A storyline structured around this conflict would make this a wonderful film, but Hollywood takes over and a typical love triangle takes the forefront. A childhood girlfriend (Elfman)returns and puts her spell on these guys. Been there, done that. The film is still left with moments worth watching and all three of the leads are pleasant and nice to watch... but, the filmmakers missed an opportunity to give something fresh. The DVD has a nice audio and video transfer.

39 Sam's review
Keeping the Faith - I found Jenna Elfman's character totally unbelievable. The idea that this tall beautiful blond woman would fall for the short nebish Ben Stiller is only plausible in the movies. Edward Norton should stick to Dramas like American History X and Fight Club. He struggles with the comedic material. The plot of two men vying for the same woman is nothing new adding the twist of one being a rabbi and one being a priest only makes the story less credible. Stiller does give a much better performance than some of his previous efforts. If you enjoy mindless comedy with the typical romantic understory then this movie is for you. Be prepared there is nothing in this movie you haven't seen before.

40 women find it romantic and men find it funny
I really enjoyed this movie and all three characters in it.. Edward Norton does a wonderful job of first time directing and telling the story. The little girl who plays Anna was superb! My husband and I watch this movie together and it's not too sappy and romantic for him, because it's also a great comedy. He's a big Ben Stiller fan! Enjoy!!

41 hit and miss comedy
Edward Norton's directorial debut, "Keeping the Faith" dishes out one of those plots that only Hollywood - in its desperation to bring a fresh approach to a stale genre - would ever dare to come up with. In this love triangle with a "twist," Ben Stiller, Edward Norton and Jenna Elfman portray a trio of best friends who grew up together on the streets of New York City, but who were separated in adolescence when Anna moved away with her family to California. The unique aspect of this particular triumvirate is that, while Anna has been away on the west coast forging a lucrative career in business for herself, Brian has become a priest and Jake has become a rabbi. Now all three are in their '30 and Anna has decided to pay her "buddies" a visit - a move that sets the story up for all the interpersonal and emotional complications that are practically de rigueur for a "Jules and Jim" scenario of this sort.

Given the rather incredible nature of the premise, "Keeping the Faith" still manages to generate some interest with the uniqueness of its religious context. Like most American movies that attempt to deal with issues of spirituality and religion, "Keeping the Faith" spends most of its time batting away at the edges of the topic rather than getting right in there and really opening up the subject for us. Indeed, very few commercial American films are even willing to tackle or explore in any great depth the role that religion and spirituality play in the lives of people, so we should at least give "Keeping the Faith" credit for trying. Of course, much of the tension in the film is supposed to be generated by the fact that one point of this triangle (the priest, Brian) has pulled himself out of the equation - or has he? But if the truth be told, the love triangle, which takes center stage in the film, is actually far less interesting than the issues of faith, of tradition vs. relevance, of spiritual commitment on the part of both clergy and laypeople that the film at least sporadically addresses.

Almost inevitably, with a film this lightweight in tone, "Keeping the Faith" seems from time to time to be afflicted with a severe case of the "cutes," particularly when it succumbs to the "golly gee, people of the cloth are just regular folk like the rest of us" syndrome that seems somehow unavoidable in films like this. Thus, despite their clerical status, Jake and Brian cuss, drink alcohol, play basketball, sing karaoke etc. just to show us what regular guys they are. We've seen this sort of religious iconoclasm used for comic effect so many times before that it has long since lost the ability to amuse.

Where the film does excel, though, is in its exploration of the issue (faced by many churches and synagogues, no doubt) of whether tradition alone can sustain a viable congregation or whether unorthodox methods may be needed to reach and retain a more "entertainment-oriented" generation of worshippers. Many times in the film, I found myself wishing that the story would concentrate less on the rigmarole surrounding the love triangle itself and more on issues like these. However, even within the confines of the romantic nature of the story, the filmmakers do manage to touch, if only superficially, on the issues of Catholic priest celibacy and interfaith marriages.

Stiller, Norton and Elfman give generally naturalistic performances, though none of them are forced to stretch their talents too much in these roles. Interestingly, famed director Milos Forman shows up as a wise old priest who sets Brian straight on the thorny issue of celibacy.

"Keeping The Faith" probably would have been a better film had it dealt with the same issues in a less frivolous and trivial context than is provided for them here. Still, we should, I suppose, be thankful that any American film is willing to acknowledge religion and spirituality as part of our lives at all. "Keeping the Faith" is, therefore, well worth checking out.

42 Skirts the issue of inter-faith relationships
When I first heard about this movie, I couldn't wait to see it. Ben Stiller and Edward Norton in Norton's directorial debut! I'm soooo there! But then I got a whiff of the promotional campaign for the film and got scared away. And then a friend heartily recommended the film so I did eventually go see it. And my verdict is... is that it's exactly the type of movie promised by the ad posters and trailers. It's all fluff and it does not deal with the issue of inter-faith relationships with any depth. And I thought the last 30 minutes of the movie was never gonna end as it relentlessly maneuvered towards that pointless happy ending. But there are still many enjoyable moments such as the scene with the hilarious karaoke salesman. Ben Stiller is also an absolute hoot and he is, hands-down, the best comedic actor working in movies today. He is extremely watchable and is worth the price of admission (well, maybe on a Tuesday night) on his own. And there is enough jokes in this film to fill an excellent 90 minute movie. Too bad the film is actually 130 minutes.

43 Surprisingly good
I have to admit I started watching this movie with a less than positive attitude. My previous encounters with Ben Stiller was either getting certain appendages stuck in zippers or having crocodilian's crispy heads removed geek style. I recognized Jenna Elfman from [Krippendorf's Tribe (1998) ASIN: 6304938748]. So I was ready for some wasted film.

After holding my breath and waiting for it to hit. I soon realized that this was a well put together movie with a good story plot and excellent execution. I was amazed at the people that were in this movie. Half the time I keep saying "oh look there is" Anne Bancroft, Eli Wallach, and many others.

Basic story of three childhood friends. One went away and the other two chose to become (now don't laugh) a priest and a rabbi. The one that went away (Anna Riley) returns as a business executive and has a magnetic personality with accoutrements to match.

The fun and the drama is when two and a half become more than friend. How will they and their world react to this? What makes the movie is not the story as much as how it is executed. And it seems that I need to re-evaluate Ben Stiller as he did a fine job with just the minimum of "spectacles, testicles, watch, wallet".

44 A total fantasy
This is a movie cut out of the mold of a love triangle, with a happy ending after the passing of a crisis. Edward Norton is a priest and Ben Stiller, his best friend is a rabbi. Will the priest break his vows? Will the rabbi marry out of his religion? See this movie to find out! This movie is a fantasy. Stiller plays the type of rabbi, a hip Hollywood filmaking crowd would like to believe exists. In fact, a rabbi who dresses trendily in punk chic and is found out to be serious with a non Jewish romantic interest would not be as tolerated by his congregation as he is in this fictional congregation in New York (and this congregation appears to be traditional, not reform). Thus, the situation created in this movie is very unreal and is for the hopelessly romatic fantasy lover. All in all, the movie is good entertainment following a tried and true romantic comedy formula.

45 Hit the nail on the head
Keeping the Faith is a movie that takes a couple of tired, overused Hollywood chliches--the love triangle and the couple who are meant to be together but sadly pushed apart by their inability to verbalize their feelings--and makes them fresh and interesting again simply by not taking them seriously. Norton has assembled a cast (himself, Ben Stiller, and Jenna Elfman) who can take these serious subjects and waltz gracefully through them, so that a movie that could be clunky and too long becomes, instead, a delightfully funny ride through the ups and downs of the Rabbi and the Priest who both love the same woman.

46 You've got to have faith.
I wasn't sure what to expect out of this movie. The idea of two best friends, one Catholic the other Jewish, growing up to become a priest and a Rabbi sounded appealing. However, the previews for the movie made the film appear to be a slapstick comedy centered around the differences of religion. However, as it turns out, Ed Norton is almost as good a director as he is an actor and prevents the movie from becoming farcical or too serious.

The movie revolves around the two said best friends and how they both end up falling in love with the same girl; a girl who used to live in their neighborhood but who is now all grown up, more beautiful than ever, and a top business executive. The film starts out great, examining the friendship and lives of the two friends. However, once the girl from next door shows up, the tone of the movie changes and instead of being a religious comedy examining the close friendship of a rabbi and priest, it becomes a dramatic romance with a few comic moments here and there. Not that the romantic angle isn't interesting, but the heart of this movie isn't about romantic love. The center of this movie is about friendship and faith.

All three of the major actors pull off strong performances and Norton continues to amaze with his range as an actor. The film also boosts a strong supporting cast which makes the film even more enjoyable to watch. A great movie overall as long as you have a little bit of faith.

47 comedy supposed to be funny
When I hear "priest and rabbi " I expect to hear the joke next. Not in tnis film. Couple funny moments in the begining and boring melodrama for the rest. Why are these guys priest and rabbi but not carpenter and musician? And such great actors like Ben Stiller and Ed Norton look just stupid and pathetic, but not funny. Maybe because of Norton's directing. Also, heroine Jenna Elfman play is unbelievably bad, reminds me Macaulay Culkin in his worst. So save your time and money. This movie neither funny nor smart.

48 lndnurse
I saw this movie on a flight to Hong Kong, and enjoyed it so much, I bought it upon my return home. Anyone who enjoys a "chick-flick" will love this one! The DVD has so many great extras, and the music is terrific. Everyone...go out and buy this movie! You won't regret it!

49 A sure to win comedy/romance:
I like ben stiller movies. I recieved this DVD for easter. I now have all his new comides, mary, meet the parents and kepping the faith. This also stars edward norton who did fight club. This movie is about a rabbi(stiller) and a priest(norton) who are in love with the same woman that they grew up with. She returns all grown up. Sparks fly and the comedy come boiling up. This movie had a splash of drama for the serious parts. It's mostly a comedy and romance movie. The DVD has great features. Get it for yourself and enjoy!

50 Better on DVD than on Video...but only if you LOVE the film
A charming tale about love, faith, and what happens when you mix the two together, Keeping the Faith is one of those films that you will either love because of the extremely likeable characters that you get to know so well, or that you will dislike because it may seem like a formula comedy that runs a bit too long (2 hours, 9 minutes). Personally I loved it for both those reasons. I came to adore all the characters, namely because in each of them I saw frail human qualities that I also shared, and also because Ben Stiller, Jenna Elfman, and Ed Norton all give superb performances that leave you laughing, crying, and laughing once again. And yet, because I loved these characters, I did not want the movie to end and therefore was pleased by its excessive length, and by the additional half an hour of footage on the DVD!

The DVD is definitely worth buying if you really liked this film because the extra features are too awesome to resist. TONS of deleted scenes and a LONG production gag reel make this a great one to own, and Edward Norton fans cannot NOT buy this disc because you can even watch the movie with Mr. Norton, aka the director and producer of the film, providing a running commentary on every aspect of the film and the making of it.

51 GREAT MOVIE, GREAT ACTORS, GREAT STORY!!!
Great movie, don't have much to say, but I'm jewish and I think that movie is great and it shows what religion is REALLY ALL ABOUT! You should believe in love and friendship! No matter who you are!!! Got to go, EVERYONE WATCH THE MOVIE, YOU'LL LOVE IT!!!!!! Xenia

52 Sweet movie
Keeping the faith is the story of 3 childhood friends.At the age of 11 Anna leaves the city,her friends Jake and Brian,and moves to another city...Eventually,Jack becomes a rabbi and Brian becomes a priest and they remain best friends.Many years later,they find out that Anna is coming back to New York.And this is the beginning of a very funny and romantic movie.

You should not expect a pure comedy out of this one,like "There's something about Mary" or "Meet the parents",otherwise you may be a bit disappointed.There are numerous funny parts,but it has also very clever and important messages about the faith in god,religions and people's understanding of religions.

All three actors have good performances in the movie but I especially liked Jenna Elfman.I should also add that while Edward Norton is one of the best actors alive today,I have certain doubts about his directing ability.He is not a great storyteller,and this reflects on the unnecessary length of the movie.

On the DVD,I recommend you to watch the deleted scenes because they are very important in my opinion,and should have stayed in the final version.(though it is understandable why they didn't..The movie would be longer than Gladiator).

It is a nice movie with an interesting storyline that I think everybody can like.."Trust me,you have not heard this one".

53 Excellent!
This movie was the greatest! The rabbi and the preist both fall head over heels for the girl. You gotta see it.

54 Surprisingly good!
Jenna Elfman is absolutely adorable in this film! Not being a fan of hers, I watched with skepticism but was completely won over within the first 20 minutes. She is superbly cast as the gregarious career-minded woman in this anticipation-wrought love triangle. Strangely enough, you really wish that both guys could win this one.

Ed Norton is brilliant as the Catholic priest rethinking his vows as he considers his love for Elfman. For anyone wondering what it must be like to be celibate and strongly tempted - this must be it. As always, Ben Stiller is wonderfully sweet and funny.

This is a beautiful, witty love story and a great date flick. I highly recommend - it's good, clean fun. The end is satisfying, but perhaps they SHOULD all just be friends!

55 Movie was great, but cut scene was better
I will say that I loved this movie. Keeping the faith was fresh and funny, however I don't think I would have loved it half as much if I hadn't gotten the DVD version with the opportunity to see the deleted scenes. I think that in some DVD's the scenes that you get are kind of a let down, but sometimes there are some scenes where you just ask yourself, why didn't they leave it in! The deleted scenes that you will find in keeping the faith are just that, scenes that are hilarious (most of them) and the scene with the cell phone is a pay off for something that was set up in the middle of the movie and then never followed through on with the release version of the film. If you watch this movie for the first time, get it on DVD and watch the deleted scenes,(but wait until you have already watched the whole film, it's even funnier when you know the setups for the scenes) You'll laugh until you have to wet nap the appolstery at Jenna Elfmann's facial expressions in the cell phone scene.

56 Love this kind of movies!
I have just seen this movie and I think it's wonderful. From beginning to end it's sweet and touching. It's the perfect movie for everyone who likes intelligent comedy with a lot of heart. All three main Actors are great. EDWARD NORTON forever!

57 Unfaithful...????
I watched this DVD yesterday...I must admit. I was expecting alot more comedy than was delivered. The movies started out very funny. I was laughing...however, it became way too serious and focused too heavily on lust more than love. The character of Anna, in my opinion was more of a qsuado-seductress than a loveable tomboyish best friend all grown up and both the Priest and the Rabbi fall for her. It is more Seduction than falling in love. I don't know. I liked the movie. But I can't say It is something somethat I would watch over and over again.....

Still worth 4 stars......Excellent directorial debut by Norton...

58 Not a Video to See Repeatedly
Being the movie illiterate that I am (and proud of it), movies like this reinforce my mindset to remain one.

The media tend to represent clergy as either morons or with-it guys. Here is perfect example. Two young clergy, shake up the faith with more worship style like David Letterman. Believers of all faiths resent having their sacredness made light of in this way. Clergy speak for God, not to entertain.

Funny parts are in this film however. Really enjoyed the young Jewish boy reciting Gen.1:1 with the changing voice. That was good.

Friendships are important. But what of the faith of these three, especially the two lovers who are (as typical Hollywood does) leaves nothing to the imagination or privacy of two adults with their intimacy. Doesn't speak much of their faith from Old or New Testaments about remaining pure for one's husband or wife.

Would not view this one again. There are videos that are watched over and over. Can't get enough of them. This doesn't come close to being in that category. Something like Chariots of Fire depicts the true nature of Christianity without stooping to such low, comic treatment as this one.

59 The Priest, Rabbi and a Loveable blonde= Faith Kept
A wonderful movie about three friends who were best buds in Jr. High only to have one of them move away. Then to reappear when they are all in their adult years. I will not go into much detail over the movie, since you can read it as listed above, what I will state however was that I thouroughly enjoyed this movie. The casting was excellent, Ben Stiller was a riot, and was not to over the top in this movie. Jenna Elfman was lovable as ever, and Edward Norton rounded at the cast brilliantly. The DVD version of the movie was great with the extra's provided. I think this where the movie really shines. Some of the deleted scene's were such a riot, I could not believe they left them out of the movie (Cell phone scene!) 5 stars to extras, I have yet to watch the commentary due to lack of time. The sound and picture quality were what to be expected on DVD. In all a worthy DVD to purchase if you like a romantic comedy. I would have purchased this movie, just for the deleted scenes, but the movie itself was so good too. I highly recommend.

60 NORTON RULES !!
Edward Norton has come to stay in the movie business. Here, he's directing for the first time. The movie flows like a hand in a velvet glove: it's smooth, nice, funny, touching. The only flaw is Elfmann. She's totally miscast here, with a bad performance. Other than this, the movie is memorable.

61 Molodramatic, mopey dopey.
Another romantic comedy, staring Ben Stiller star of Mystery Men, Directed and co.-starring Edward Norton, and the love of both of their lives Jenna Elfman, of TV's Dharma & Gregg. Probably one of the funniest romantic comedies, great chemistry between everyone and a generally witty screenplay. Ben Stiller is a Rabbi, Edward Norton is a priest, and Jenna Elfman is a workaholic, long time friend of both of them. Ben and Edward have not seen Jenna in over 10 years and don't realize that she will be completely different. She is not a tough tom boy anymore, she is a grown up women. Finally they meet, and eventually they both figure out that they are in love with her, it just takes to much of the movie to find that out, and that is what is depressing. It does have a wildly funny, witty script, great chemistry, and good performances, but towards the end turns to Melodramatic, dopey and dumb. It can be funny, it can be cute, and it can be enjoyable, but some things can't save films, such as the fact that I believe that Jenna Elfman ends up with the wrong guy, and it is shocking to think that just that can ruin a movie, but it did, I have no interest in seeing it again because she ended up with the wrong guy. A complicated, mopey, dopey, melodramatic Jerry Springer sort of movie,, just you average love triangle film.

62 Faithfully Kept Comedy...=)
This was a wonderful movie, if not a tad too long. Funny, thoughtful, and at times, damn-near heartwarming. Ed Norton has always been a stellar actor, but never so warmly appealing before as he is as Father Brian Finn, an Irish Catholic Priest in Manhattan. This is also Norton's directorial debut. A good start for a great star! His best friend in the movie is Ben Stiller's character(played with humor and an affective broodiness)Rabbit Jacob Schrahmn. The 2 were childhood buddies who remained strong friends into adulthood, both pursuing careers related to their religions: Judaism and Catholicism. When their long lost friend from childhood Anna walks back into their lives they both fall for her, and this is where the movie cooks with fun, sprit, a subtle wit, and warmth of heart. There are some tense moments with confrontation, questioning of faith,and you really feel bad for Anna and for Father Brian. The only bad things I can say about this film is that it is predictable, it's a bit long for the kind of plot that it has ( a thin one) and you are never really given enough insight into Stiller's character as to why Anna falls for him as opposed the the more lovable priest. And it would have made a more interesting plot to have them in a tryst instead anyway. But all in all, there is a fun spirit to this film. IT discusses religion as if religion is an agreeable belief the world over, and we just can't agree on the structure of which to base it on. It has strong likable characters, a fair if not great soundtrack, and enjoyable dialougle. A fantabulous date flick be you Jewish, Catholic or even Atheist!

63 Frivolous Fun
KEEPING THE FAITH is set in NYC where Pastor Brian(Norton), and Rabbi Jacob(Stiller) have their friendship tested when an old mutual female friend, Anna(Elfman), pays them an unexpected visit. Of course, they both fall head over heels with the successful young wall-street type and chaos ensues as the seductions and self-analyses commence.

The subsequent turmoil turns in some of the best original comedy I've seen from a movie in a long time. From the Irish bar run by a Punjabi, through the "Heroes of the Torah" - the comedy is delivered thick and fast. In fact, I cannot say enough about the humor that is dished out in this movie. It is simply fun!

In his directorial debut, Edward Norton does a fine job of handling some pretty outstanding talent and is able to hold his own on-screen with Stiller. Ben Stiller is true to form and provides a character of some depth while managing not to take himself too seriously - a talent that is required of the best comedy actors.

Some exceptional supporting characters provide another uplift to this movie and I'll mention by name Ken Lueng who plays a karaoke salesman and Brian George - the 'Irish' bartender.

I would be lying if I didn't tell you that I didn't want to watch KEEPING THE FAITH and that my wife talked me into it. So here's the tip to all the married/dating guys out there: buy this movie and watch it with the wife/girlfriend - you will earn some brownie points and have a pretty good time yourselves!

64 Few laughs in tired script about Catholics vs. Jews
Being a keen fan of Ben Stiller & Edward Norton (Elfman is very over rated) several friends and I went along to see this much hyped film that provided few genuine laughs, broken up by long periods of boring dialogue and hackneyed cliches about Catholics & Jews...it was almost like watching that old 70's sitcom "Bridget loves Bernie". To be honest it become a tedious quest to see if I could stop from falling asleep from the poor quality script !

The plot devices used in this film are as old as the hills, the jokes you can see coming from a hundred miles away....and Elfman is unbelievably weak compared to Stiller & Norton. Elfman is obviously trying to expand her horizons beyond her one dimensional TV character in "Dharma & Greg"...but this effort by her falls flat on her face !! This cliche riddled movie just meandered on and on like a lost ship without a rudder for what seemed like an eternity !!

A dissapointing romance that may possibly only be funny to older religious types that enjoy the old Barry Fitzgerald / Bing Crosby movies !

65 Not only can Norton act but direct!
After seeing the trailer for Keeping the Faith I planned to run away from ever seeing it. The trailer was packed with silly physical comedy pratfalls and nonsense - not the kind of film to see and certainly not the kind in which one would expect to find an actor like Edward Norton starring, let alone directing. But pushed by trusted friends who assured me of the film's quality, I broke down and saw Keeping the Faith. It turned out to be a bright spot in a dreary 2000 moviegoing year.

Norton's film follows the simple comedic/romantic comedy scenario that three childhood friends (Norton, Stiller and Elfman) are reuniting after more than a decade apart. Of course the twist is that the boys have become a priest and a rabbi (sounds like a bad joke) and the girl became a powerful business consultant - some would say pretty, but this is Elfman generally more coltish than pretty. The three are reunited and both men find themselves attracted to Elfman (God only knows why), for Stiller it's a problem because she's not Jewish and he fears upsetting his mother and the synagogue. Norton on the other hand has to confront his vows. Naturally, as one would expect from such a movie, everything works out, people laugh, cry and it all ends wonderfully.

Pretty run-of-the-mill stuff, but Norton does give it an edge. Either Norton or the scriptwriter have infused a tremendous amount of personality into the priest and rabbi characters. Of course with two talents such as Norton and Stiller it sould not be surprising these two will deliver good performances. The pratfall scenes from the trailer weigh-down the first few minutes of the film but after that, the film exhibits what good dialogue and talented actors can do. Good comedic bits and many, many sly cultural references from Tony Robbins to Rainman find their way into the film. Even Elfman is semi-interesting and almost attractive in her blah role as the love interest. At the end too, Norton's movie has actually made the audience care and suffer with the two male leads, even if we know how it will end. Good job. Hopefully next time he'll make something with a bit more punch though.

66 Alright film
The storyline was somewhat unbelievable, but the movie was fine overall. A Jewish rabbi and a Catholic priest both have fallen in love with a childhood friend, beauty Jenna Elfman, who is in love with the rabbi. It is a story about a priest's struggling with his vocation, and coming to terms with it, as well a struggle of a rabbi looking for a Jewish wife. After the rabbi admits he has fallen in love with Elfman, she admits she's converting to the Jewish faith. The movie had some comical parts, and at the end, it makes you smile since they have overcome their conflicts.

67 Why a DVD's extra features matter
KEEPING THE FAITH is a fine example of how extra features on a DVD can help change your mind about a film. When I first saw it, my immediate reaction was total disappointment. It's not that I thought the film bad, exactly. It was just that the previews had made it out to be a hilarious romantic comedy, and it wasn't exactly splittin' my sides.

When you look at the deleted scenes and hear the audio commentary, it becomes clear that producer/director Ed Norton wasn't trying to make the film the studio was selling. It's not that he comes out and says, "Disney's marketing department screwed me." But you see through his dialogue with his writer that he made conscious choices away from extremely funny material. He wasn't trying to make a hilarious movie, just a good story about three friends.

This is particularly evident when viewing the deleted scenes. Though completely shot and scored, Norton decides to axe what is clearly the funniest orgasm scene since Meg Ryan faked it in a restaurant. You also see how much of Ben Stiller's naturally funnier self was edited out. Why? Norton says, to the audible chagrin of his writer, that it didn't really fit in the movie he was trying to make.

Whether you agree with him on this and other choices, the fact is that if the movie he was trying to make had been marketed, it would've garnered more appreciation.

Still, Norton didn't quite succeed at making a solid romance, either. It's not the kind of movie you'll watch over and over again. After the engaging set up, there aren't really any plot twists, much less unexpected outcomes. It's just another romance set in New York. Lacking either remarkable comedy or profound insight, the film easily releases you from its grasp once you see it. Norton has traded the innovative promise of the plot for mere likability. I think, perhaps, that Norton was trying so hard not to cause religious offense that he winds up seeming almost gun shy of his own subject matter. Or maybe the sudden rewrite of a huge chunk of the movie days prior to filming is what tripped things up.

What I really think sinks the film, though, is Norton's own character. He's just not a plausible romantic presence. At no point do you ever feel like Brian might actually GET Anna, so his entire presence is superflous to the romantic plot. Worse, the storyline depends on him going beyond being hurt by Anna's inevitable rejection, into the area of absolutely unprofessional conduct. It just doesn't make any sense what he does in the end, and yet without his action, the story can't advance.

All this aside, students of film will want to look at the DVD version of this movie, just because it's a great case study of the indirect tension between studio and filmmaker, and, to a lesser extent, between director and writer. Casual viewers in search of a night of light New York romance would probably do better watching WHEN HARRY MET SALLY again.

68 Surprisingly good
Edward Norton's performance may not be the bright spot in this film, but it's not bad. Jenna Elfman and Ben Stiller are very good. This is a nicely done story and it paints a fairly true to life picture. If the film is intended to be funny, it fails for the most part but it is nevertheless very engaging and entertaining. Be sure to check out the deleted scenes on the DVD.

69 Almost PERFECT!
Ok, I know it is very difficult to believe that yet another romantic comedy is coming out, and that in all probability it is gonna make you sick with corney dialouge and predictable jokes and leave you wondering why these people fell for eachother in the first place. That is one thing that is GREAT about keeping the faith--you see the chemistry between all three characters (Father Brian, Rabbi Jake and Anna Riley) and dont wonder for a second what interests them in eachother. Yes its predictable and even sappy, but it is also truly charming, well written and funny. You really care about the characters and when you listen to them talk to eachother you feel as if you are really listening to old friends chat. All three actors are so perfect for their roles and Norton's first timed directing doesn't let us down. Along with the love triangle part of the story there is some really good discussions about faith, life, and forgivness. I love this movie from the opening to closing credits--see it, cuz if you wanna regain your faith (no pun intended, hehe) in romantic comedies, you will too!

70 Dong Rules
Not only is this movie, funny and interesting, but it features Dong the music salesman. Dong adds an entire hilarious dimension to this film. You could watch another movie, but they are terrible...

71 Good God
A charming light hearted look at love, religion, relationships and friendship. Definitely worth seeing if just for the "nightmare date" Stiller goes on.

72 1 word = awesome
The next time you feel totally hopeless and sad over the endless stream of bad, unfunny comedies and pathetic, unmoving romances I suggest you watch Keeping the Faith. It'll put a smile on your face, a tear in your eye, and hope for the future of movies back in your heart.

In short, this movie is awesome. It is a superb blend of side-splitting laughs, happy ending romance, and good old-fashioned priest-rabbi jokes. The script is probably one of the best things to come out of the romantic comedy genre in a while, and impressively enough is not resigned to basing all of its jokes solely on the priest-rabbi thing. From physical scenes to straight dialogue this movie never stops delivering the good times. But it is not strictly punch line after punch line - amongst all of this humor there is a genuine story of friendship, family, love, humanity and yes! even religion. And, unlike so many movies today, there is actual character development and an ability to become attached to those characters.

Of course, a lot of the attachment you have to the people on the screen is due to the awesome people who portray those characters. Ben Stiller and Edward Norton were the PERFECT picks for the lead roles of rabbi and priest, respectively. They worked together ingeniously, playing off one another in the most amusing and remarkable manner. Jenna Elfman played Anna beautifully, and is so totally adorable and endearing that even if you want to hate her because she is so beautiful, you can't. She's a great comic, and holds her own against Ben Stiller who I personally think is one of the funniest kids around. I'm willing to bet the farm that a good deal of the scenese between any combination of these three was filled with improvisation (such as the scene where Norton drifts into a Dustin-Hoffman-as-Rainman manner of speaking, just for kicks). The three are fabulous together.

My highest suggestion - don't miss this movie. See it, rent it, buy it....whatever. But chances are you haven't seen anything this good in a while, and won't again very soon.

73 Jenna Elfman, ooooooh
The story is good and funny, and the filming looks wonderful.

Do NOT miss the extras on the DVD, especially the scene with Anna (Jenna Elfman) and her vibrating cell phone. It is definitely one of the funniest and sexiest scenes I have seen in a long while.

74 Funny, impressive directoral debut
It's clear Edward Norton was getting a little fed up -- and probably a little worried -- with Hollywood's insistence so far of pegging him as a psycho, weirdo, thief, whathavyou. Here he takes matters into his own hands and directs a movie HE wanted to do. He surprised me yet again with a solid and likable performance as a young priest with an understandable crush on Jenna Elfman, who in turn is in love with his best friend, a Rabbi. Funny & Recommended.

75 Fun, Thoughtful, Romantic - Great movie!
This was not your typical romantic comedy by any stretch. A priest, a rabbi, and a business woman sounds like the beginning of a bad joke but it actually is the scenario for a wonderful film that explores faith, friendship, love, tradition, and conviction.

The basic premise of the film are three friends: a priest Brian (Norton), his best friend a rabbi, Jake (Ben Stiller) who both fall in love with a childhood friend Anna (Jenna Elfman). The story uses each of these characters to explore various issues. Anna is presented as the workaholic person driven by the need to succeed. She says when we first meet her, "I work harder than God. If God had hired me, the world would have been finished by Thursday." Jake is pressured by his Jewish community to find a nice Jewish girl to settle down with. Brian is a devote Catholic whose vow of celibacy is tempted by his love for Anna. Brian and Jakes friendship is tested over their mutual love for the same girl.

While sounding like a complex plot, Norton (who debuts as a director with this film) does an amazing job of telling a story, exploring these issues, making you laugh, and adding a good solid love story to boot.

I was struck by how this film is very representative of an entire generation. It's sort of a romantic Friends episode dealing with the complications that arise when faith conflicts with love and tradition. I think it speaks to a lot of young people who have grown up in various traditions and are then confronted with difficult decisions (and often associated guilt) as they wrestle with how to balance their lives.

What is really important in life? What is the difference between faith and tradition? How do I move from success to significance? Is love more important than a career? What does friendship look like?

These are the questions that the film strives to raise for the viewer. Perhaps the line that best summaries this thread through the film is given by Jake towards the end of the film, in which he says: "We live in a really complex world. A world in which boundaries and definitions are blurring and bleeding into each other in ways that challenge us not just as Jews, but as human beings."

The movie is a success based on the likeability of the characters alone. Norton does an amazing job of building the characters and the depth of their relationships very quickly. One scene in particular, at a diner where Brian imitates "Rainman," does a phenomenal job of showing the friendship and chemistry between these three people. This is perhaps Elfman's strongest performance yet on film. She does a great job of portraying the driven business type but with enough charm and sophistication to still keep your interest and affection. Norton and Stiller pull off great performances that give you the sense that they have been life-long friends. You don't come to just know the characters, you come to genuinely like them.

Throughout the movie there a numerous laughs and moments that are too funny. I saw this on DVD and the gag scenes and deleted scenes are not to be missed. I'm surprised they kept some of the deleted scenes out of the movie as I think it could have helped build the characters even further.

All in all, a great movie - one that caught me by surprise. A great date movie and one that any Gen X person in their 20s or 30s should see.

76 great religious story
i thought this was a great effort by edward norton as a director. i especially loved the religious implications involved with the priest and the rabbi and the worldly woman. it was well done to show that men of two different religions could be pals, even of two religions that have fought each other previously. it is possible to be friends and have different religious beliefs.

77 Romantic comedy...but not enough comedy
Edward Norton, Ben STiller, and Jenna Elfman star in this attempt at a romantic comedy that takes itself a little to seriously. Considering the topic of Religion that comes up, it's hard for there not to be some seriousness. The three of them are friends growing up together, and when they are in 8th grade, Anna(elfman) moves away to California. Jake(Stiller) and Brian(Norton, who is also the director of the film as well) remain close friends that grow up to dedicate themselves to their religion. Brian is a priest. Jake, a rabbi. Then, Anna comes back into their lives. At this point, I knew romance would enter between two of them at some point. THe chemistry between Stiller and Elfman was great. The film wasn't bad, it certainly wasn't great by any means. There was way too much time between the laughs in the film. In my opinion, I think Ben Stiller is the glue of this film. If it had been someone else playing his character, I don't think I could've stayed interested in it. Not only does romance enter, but also the whole religion issue(there has to be some conflict, right)Jake being a jewish Rabbi, being in love with Anna, who isn't jewish. The film does make you think about faith and where our faith lies. The secondary cast, which includes director Milos Forman, Anne Bancroft, who I thought was perfect as the jewish mother, and Eli Wallach, is a great addition to the film. It really was a cute story, and It has a happy ending. If you are expecting to laugh all the way through, you may be a little disappointed. Otherwise, it is a good rental.

78 Ed Norton - Stick to dramatic acting
This film is embarassing. I have liked everything Stiller and Norton have done individually but man this film is bad. Promoted as a comedy, there are very few funny moments other than what you see in the trailer. The rest is a confused badly paced romance that never has any tension. The fact that these guys are supposed to be clergy is laughable. There is no chemistry between Stiller and Elfman and Norton's direction is obviously saved by editors.

79 At last!
At last a film which breaks the mould of slapstick comedy. I thoroughly enjoyed this film because of its simplicity and directness. It thrives on the performance of Jenna Elfman who is stunning as Anna, a ruthless business woman who is inseparable from her mobile phone. Ben Stiller is as funny as usual whilst Ed Norton shows us once again his incredible range as an actor. Some of the shots of New York are a joy to behold (particularly at night). Obviously, it won't rank among the greatest films ever but it has an indelible charm and will appeal to all generations. The extra's on the DVD are quite good, keep an eye on the deleted scene 'Anna and her phone' which is hilarious. Anne Bancroft as Jake's (Ben Stiller) mother plays the role to perfection. It was clear that everyone who took part in this film enjoyed acting in it as i did watching it. ps: great to watch with your girlfriend

80 Brilliant!!
It would appear that this movie would be another cheesy chick flick (I mean really: A comedy about love between a priest, a rabbi, and a business woman!) Well, it wasn't. Very clever directing by Norton himself. Very involving plot keeps the viewer in the story. And lets not forget....JENNA ELFMAN is smoking! Definitely a wining choice!

81 Good Evening's Entertainment At Home
This is a pleasant, good movie that you will enjoy but it is hardly a knockout. Both Norton and Stiller have done better movies but they are both likable and funny in this romantic comedy triangle over their childhood girl friend. I've never seen Jenna Elfman before and she's cute as the romantic interest for both men, who just happen to be the hippest religious leaders in town. Norton is a priest and Stiller is a rabbi and they've been friends since childhood. This may have been funnier if Norton has been an Episcopalian or a Unitarian, giving him the opportunity to push his character further romantically. Norton's being a Catholic priest instead puts some real restraints on the role. Norton did a good directing job. Probably because he spent most of his time directing, his acting job needs only about ten percent of his talent in this light piece. I prefer him as an actor in films like the much weightier "Fight Club." This is a perfect vehicle for Stiller though and he probably has a long career ahead in playing romantic comedy leads similar to this one.

82 I love the film, but what does this "BANANA" mean?
It was a great thing to see the film at Tokyo Film Festival and see the "real" Ed Norton, who came to the festival for promotion of the film! After the screening, he participated in Q & A session, where audiences were free to ask him questions about the film.

I found the film plot well designed and eleborated, and thought Ed Norton did a good job as a director. The film well presented the mojor theme-- the difficulties of love between man and woman with different religeous beliefs and of understanding and acceptance of different thoughts and practice of religeons.

At the Q & A session at the film festival, many of my questions concerning the film became solved, but here is one more thing that I want to know: "What is this "BANANA" about?"

This might be simply because of the language problem, but could anybody give me an answer?

83 One of the best movies ever
I went and saw this movie with my Catholic friend, and being Jewish this movie seemed all to appropriate for us. Also since we are familiar with each other's religious views, the movie hit close to home. I seriously could not stop laughing, and I recommend you see it with anyone. It's always better when art imitates life, as it does with this movie. It's accurasy into the Jewish faith is a little off, but it is still one of the best movies ever.

84 Excruciatingly Unfunny
This is the most unfunniest comedy ever. How they made the comercials hillarious but not the movie. This is a horrible movie! Don't waste YOUR faith watching this!

85 Not funny
Hey, like everyone, I saw the cool trailer, the nice commercials on TV so I went to see it in the theater, and I must say that I was really disappointed, except for the first narrating scene which made me smile and a few (3-4) other funny moments like the Rabbi trading cards, this comedy is probably one of the dullest and most pointless movies in recent filmmaking.

The plot at first seemed appealing, it talks about a Priest and a Raby who are best friends and in love of a girl they knew from school. And when she moves back to NY, they starts seeing her again...

Well, the entire movie is boring with some really endless moments of me and my friends wondering were the plot was going.

My advice, don't waist your time or money.

86 Uplifting, Funny....Make You Feel Good
It is hard to believe this is the 1st time these three (Elfman, Norton, and Stiller) have been together in a film. The chemistry was excellent. The storyline about three friends reunited-along with a good soundtrack make for a touching movie. Have a first date tonight? This romantic comedy is the perfect movie to break the ice. The smiles they put on are contagious and you will find yourself and your date smiling and laughing at the same parts. Overall, this is a very clever and entertaining movie. Must be bought.

87 LAUGHTER DOES GOOD LIKE A MEDICINE
"Keeping the Faith" is one of the most stellar movies I have seen in a long time, tying together laughter, love and people of faith. The actors pull you into their childhood, and draws you into that piece of time in your own life.

As one learns as they live longer, our lives may change logistically and personally, yet somehow, some relations will remain, when stemmed from childhood/neighborhood seasons. Irony of life is, this dynamic makes for strange relationships. You are guaranteed to laugh and be charmed in your heart as these actors so refresheningly bring people of different faiths into the common denominator of love and life.

88 one word describes this movie - hysterical
this is one of the funniest movies of the last few years. from the opening in the bar to the closing at the senior center, the movie never departs from its comic theme while still maintaining character development. Thumbs up to Ben Stiller and Edward Norton, who manage to pull off their roles with aplomb, and never falling into the trap of turning a funny scene into a forced gag. The DVD version has the deleted scenes and gag reels - the "Anna and her cell phone" reel is worth the purchase price all by itself.....

89 Hear the one about a priest, the rabbi, and his girlfriend?
Much more of a Ben Stiller versus Edward Norton fan, I was pleasantly surprised by this light-hearted comedy that was not only an acting but directing vehicle for Norton. A drunken priest pours out his heart to a sympathetic barkeep (played by wonderful character actor Brian George of Babu Bat/Seinfeld fame), recalling the series of events that brought him to this sorry state. The plotline is fairly simple- childhood friends Elfman, Stiller, and Norton form a fast bond, Elfman moves away, and the boys are a duo. Then their lives take a decidedly righteous turn when they both enter the church and temple as priest and rabbi. They set about reforming their neighborhood through their ministries, dubbed the "god squad" by those in the know. Before they realize it, years have gone by, and though Norton can't get married, there are no such restraints on a rabbi. Stiller is set up on a series of failed dates; the women are inexplicably drawn to fawn over him in a disgusting manner. Then enter Jenna Elfman, the childhood friend who has grown into glorious womanhood. The trio renew ties, and both Stiller and Norton feel an attraction to her. I'm sure you can guess what happens from here- boy priest denies attraction to girl, so girl goes for boy rabbi and secretly starts seeing him. Girl is a shiksa, which doesn't bode well for boy rabbi because of his mother, played with usual aplomb by Anne Bancroft. Boy priest decides to throw away priesthood and declare love for girl, but she tells him she's in love with boy rabbi. Boy priest punches boy rabbi's lights out, and falls from proverbial wagon. This film is endearing on a very sappy level, if one is disposed to that type of film, which I am. It's a consummate "date" movie. It moves along at a good clip, has a few good laughs, though the ending tends to get bogged down in working itself out. But all in all, an admirable effort for Norton.

90 Funny Movie
I liked, this movie very funny Edward Norton did a good job with this Ben Stiller was good, Jenna Elfmen was great I loved this movie made me, laugh you'll like it.

91 Romantic, hip, and funny as hell!
This is a movie about a priest named Brian Finn (Edward Norton) and a rabbi named Jake Schram (Ben Stiller) in New York City. They're young, popular, down to earth, and are totally committed to their respective religions. Before that, when they were kids, there was this girl--a totally cool chick just like them, down to earth and decent. The three of them were like peas and carrots together but she had to move away, upsetting at first, but ultimately making Brian and Jake best friends by themselves. They're adults now, and she comes back to NYC to visit for business, and things get VERY interesting. If you've ever had the whole "is [s]he Jewish?" dilemna, you'll love this movie. Even if you haven't, this romantic comedy breaks all cliches and tells a most unique story. Ben Stiller and Edward Norton, if you're reading this, keep doing these kinds of movies! Pop some popcorn, invite your boyfriend or girlfriend over, and put on this movie! You'll love it.

92 A Divine Comedy
There have been so many romantic comedies produced that it is difficult for a film to break out due to the depth and breadth of the competition. This is one that does. This wonderfully funny romantic comedy takes a fresh approach, portraying a romance involving not one, but two men of the cloth. They are not even of the same cloth as one is a Catholic priest and the other a Jewish rabbi. The girl of their dreams is also the girl of their youth as the three were best friends in grammar school. Now, after many years of separation, Anna (Jenna Elfman) returns and both men fall immediately and madly in love with her.

The film is chock full of religious humor and sharp-witted dialogue that keeps you grinning between guffaws. The romance is syrupy sweet and the actors have such great chemistry that it is easy to believe they have been friends all their lives. Edward Norton produced, directed and starred in this gem and he shows himself to be adept at spinning a magical yarn with very few flaws. This was Norton's first directorial effort and it bodes well for his future on the other side of the lens. His work with the actors was marvelous, and his pacing of the film was excellent. The film flowed very pleasantly from scene to scene and kept the viewer amused and immersed. If there is any criticism of the film it is its length. It dwells a bit too long on the schmaltzy romance and takes to long to wrap it up at the end. These are minor issues in an otherwise enchanting film.

The entire cast is terrific. Norton plays Father Brian Finn and is funny and affable in the role. Rabbi Jacob Schram is played by Ben Stiller, whose comedic star is on the rise. In this film, he outdoes his wonderful performance in "There's Something About Mary" with a character that is just as amusing but more complete, with greater range. Anne Bancroft is also fantastic as the rabbi's mother. She has the New York Jewish mother routine down pat, right down to the accent. A dynamite performance.

The real news in this film though, is Jenna Elfman. She lights up the screen with her enthusiasm and her charming girl-next-door beauty. She is dynamic, hilarious, sensitive, sexy and lovable and pretty much steals the show. After her terrific performance in "Edtv, she proves once again that she is a talented actor and comedian. One can only hope that the popularity of this film gives her access to more and better parts.

This fabulous romantic comedy is highly entertaining and enchanting. I rated it a 9/10. It is especially funny if you happen to be Catholic or Jewish. I highly recommend it.

93 An cool romantic smart comedy.
Directorial Debut for actor:Edward Norton(Primal Fear, Fight Club) is impressive, he shows a great story telling, also he`s the second star for the film. The plot:Two friends of differents regilions(Ben Stiller and Norton) are the best of friends, until a woman, they didn`t see for twenty years named Anna(Jenna Elfman in a charmimg performance). The three are together since, they were kids, But Anna is in love with one of them. The two friends are also in love with her.

DVD`s has an fine amamorphic Widescreen(1.85:1) transer and an good Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround. An average commentary track by the director & screenwriter but the best extra is Deleted Scenes and Outtakes are about 40 Mins. Grade:B+.

94 Great Comedy with an excellent romance involved also
When a movie attempts to mix comedy and romance together usually it does not work. This movie is able to mix comedy and romance perfectly. I believe that Jenna Elman did an excellent job in this movie I have always been a fan of her show Dharma and Greg, and I hope that I see Jenna Elfman in more movies because she has some great talent. Ben Stiller what can you say another great comedy. In the last three years this man has been in such movies as There's Something About Mary (I highly recommend you buy), Mystery Men good comedy and Meet the Parents (Watch this movie in the theatres it is hillarious). Every comedy this man does turns into gold. Also Edward Norton does a good job in this movie, I am not usually a big fan of his movies such as Fight Club, but I have to say Norton did a good job as the priest. Buy this movie this is a romantic comedy any man, woman, or child can enjoy!

95 Romantic Triangle Comedy That WORKS!
'Keeping the Faith' is one of the funniest, smartest, warmest comedies of the last several years, and marks a wonderful directorial debut for costar Edward Norton. It works on many levels; as a loving look at relationships, on the common ground Judaism and Catholicism shares in compassion towards people, in embracing love, no matter what obstacles might arise...and it does all this while respecting different religions, which makes this a very unique and special film!

Norton and Ben Stiller play lifelong friends, who, as children, meet a fabulous, funny girl who they bond with. After she moves away, the two grow up, becoming a priest and a rabbi...then the girl returns, as a successful businesswoman, and the friendship is renewed...until romance enters the picture!

Each character is unique and likeable; Norton is a sweet, funny klutz, endearing in his awkwardness; Stiller is compassionate and quick-witted, dealing with his Temple's matchmaking efforts with wry humor; Jenna Elfman (who has NEVER been lovelier onscreen) is both wise and vulnerable, and totally believable as a person both guys would fall in love with.

Major issues are addressed in the film (a Priest's vow of celibacy, interfaith marriages, religious discrimination), and are dealt with and resolved in such a positive, loving manner that you wonder why these issues ever BECOME problems! All this reflects well on Edward Norton, who shows remarkable sensitivity as both a cowriter and director!

The supporting cast is marvelous; Anne Bancroft is fabulous as Stiller's mother, Eli Wallach and Ron Rifkin, as a rabbi and synagogue leader, respectively, are equally good; director Milos Forman is terrific as Father Havel, Norton's mentor. Two other supporting players should be singled out, as well; Lisa Edelstein has a GREAT slapstick scene with Stiller, as the Jewish 'Date from Hell', and Brian George is hilarious as a "Sikh/Christian with Jewish inlaws" bartender that Norton confides in.

There are a LOT of great one-liners, inspired scenes, and a resolution that is both believable and satisfying. The DVD edition offers even MORE to love; Norton's very funny and wise commentary about the making of the film, deleted scenes, and a VERY funny gag reel are special features you CAN'T find anywhere else!

This film is a MUST for your collection, a 'feel-good' movie that you can enjoy, again and again! I HIGHLY recommend it!